Home
Poetry
Song for the Heroes
I wonder sometimes
if the soldiers lying
under the soil,
wrapped in their coats like beggars
sleeping under an
arch, their hands filled with leaves
could take
vengeance for once on the men who sent them,
coming back like
beggars, seeing the homes and fields
that their
obedience lost to them, the men of all countries
whether they would
have anything to say
as ghosts at frosty
windows to sons or brothers
other than this: "
Obedience is death."
If you are willing
to die, then choose obedience.
"We who are here
now, men of all nations,
our hands full of
twigs, stones on our eyes,
half-afraid of what
we have done (but that is forgotten
a short wild dream,
when we were other men
not ourselves but
now we are ourselves again
tradesmen, farmers,
students it is we who are telling you)
you must choose
carefully, for your life, and not only your life
will depend on it,
in years or days, between believing
like us, that by
obedience you could help or profit
the land, the
fields, the people; and saying "Death is obedience."
"Because we know
now that every cause is just
and time does not
discriminate between the aggressor
and the dead child,
the Regrettable Necessity
and the foul
atrocity, the grass is objective
and turns all
citizens into green mounds
we have had time,
as soldiers always have time,
resting before
Plataea. or Dunkirk or Albuhera
to think about
obedience though we will still spring up
at the whistle; it
is too late to withdraw that someone must pay
for all this, and
it will be the people.
"We have nothing to
tell you but this: to choose carefully
and if you must
still obey, we are ready,
your fathers,
grandfathers, great-grandfathers, to find you
a place at our dry
table, to greet you as soldiers
with a dry nod, and
sit, elbow to elbow
silently for always
under the sky of soil:
but know you are
choosing. When they begin to appeal
to your better
nature, your righteous indignation,
your pity for men
like yourselves, stand still,
look down and see
the lice upon your hide.
It may be that you,
or else your children, at last
will put down your
hand and crush them. But if not
remember that we
are waiting, good men as you,
not fools, but men
who knew the price of obeying,
the lice for what
they were, the Cause for a fraud,
hoped for no good
and cherished no illusions;
and we will see
your mounds spring up in clusters
beside our own, and
welcome you with a nod,
crucified like us
all, all fellow-ghosts together,
not fooled by the
swine, but going with open eyes.
You have only to
speak once they will melt like smoke,
you have only to
meet their eyes they will go
howling like devils
into bottomless death
but if you choose
to obey, we shall not blame you
for every lesson is
new. We will make room for you
in this cold hall,
where every cause is just.
Perhaps you will go
with us to frosty windows
putting the same
choice as the years go round
eavesdropping when
the Gadarenes call our children
or sit debating
when will they disobey?
wrapped in our
coats against the impartial cold."
All this I think
the buried men would say
clutching their
white ribs and their rusted helmets
nationless bones,
under the still ground.